Opinion List Quick Tip
Opinion Table Exmample Photo

For more detailed help on the new features of the Opinion List, download the overview by clicking here.

Open Help

West Virginia Judiciary

Home | Contact | Employment | Sitemap

Opinions and Memorandum Decisions of the
Intermediate Court of Appeals

Fall 2023 Opinion List

Links to all decisions filed in the current term of court are listed in the table below. Are you looking for an opinion list from a prior term of court? If so, please visit the Information & Search page. Opinions from the September 1991 term of court to the present day are available online.

The new integrated decision list combines all of the decisions issued during a court term, identified using case type and decision type codes. To re-sort the l8ist quickly, click any of the column headers (except case number). For more information about using the decision list and for an explanation of the codes, review the page: About the Decision List.

When the page loads, the Date Filed column is sorted descending.

QUICK TIP: For more help on using the opinion table, click the Open Opinion Table Help to the right on the page.

Current Term of Court Opinions and Memorandum Decisions
Current Term of Court Opinions and Memorandum Decisions
Decision Type
Date Filed Case No. Case Name Case Type Decision Type
11/29/2023 22-ICA-243 Jay Folse v. G. Russell Rollyson, Jr. and John McCuskey, Jr. CIV-O SEP
11/16/2023 22-ICA-327 Abigail Shoemaker, Mary Shoemaker, and Chris Shoemaker v. Tazewell County Public Schools and Kimberly Benson TCR SO
11/16/2023 22-ICA-243 Jay Folse v. G. Russell Rollyson, Jr. and John McCuskey, Jr. CIV-O SO
11/16/2023 22-ICA-301 Andrea Dale Dye v. Farmers & Mechanics Mutual Insurance Company of West Virginia TCR MD
11/16/2023 22-ICA-150 Nicholas A. Ghaphery, D.O., as Personal Representative of the Estate of Austin Ghaphery v. Wheeling Treatment Center, LLC and John Schultz, M.D. TCR MD
11/15/2023 22-ICA-111, 22-ICA-225, and 22-ICA-226 Statoil USA Onshore Properties, Inc. v. Matthew Irby, State Tax Commissioner of West Virginia; Statoil USA Onshore Properties, Inc. v. Matthew Irby, State Tax Commissioner of West Virginia; and Equinor USA Onshore Properties, Inc. v. Matthew Irby, State Tax Commissioner of West Virginia ADM SO
11/15/2023 22-ICA-233 James Atkinson v. NCI Nursing Corps and MedTox Laboratories, Inc. TCR SO
11/15/2023 22-ICA-249 David G. Maher and Amy C. Maher v. Camp 4 Condominium Association, Inc. TCR SO
11/14/2023 22-ICA-173 Mark Scafella v. Erie Insurance Company and Stanley Geho TCR SO
11/14/2023 22-ICA-311 Joseph Miker v. Monongalia County Board of Education ADM MD
11/13/2023 22-ICA-277 West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources Office of Health Facility Licensure and Certification v. Heart 2 Heart Volunteers, Inc. d/b/a Serenity Hills Life Center ADM SO
11/13/2023 22-ICA-207 Earl J. Nicholson and Joyce A. Nicholson v. Severin POA Group, LLC, Antero Resources Corporation, Rockwell Resources, LLC, JEC Production LLC, and Robert R. Jones, et al. TCR SO
11/13/2023 22-ICA-168 Donald C. Nichols v. Maroney Williams Weaver & Pancake PLLC and Patrick K. Maroney TCR SO
11/8/2023 22-ICA-141 C.S. v. Steven Grow, Donald Fishel, Chris Jensen, Sandralee Jensen, Matthew Whitcomb, Don Wrye, Anthony Naegle, and Christopher Michael Jensen CIV-O MD
11/8/2023 22-ICA-123 Ronald Hardy, Ralph Manuel, Edgel Dudleson, Ricky Miller, James Cruey, Mark Scott, and Gary Scott v. 3M Company, Mine Safety Appliances Company, LLC, American Optical Corporation, Cabot CSC Corporation, Cabot Corporation, Eastern States Mine Supply Company, and Raleigh Mine and Industrial Supply TCR MD
11/8/2023 22-ICA-269 Jeffrey Darago, Executor of the Estate of Oscar Darago v. Rodney Darago and Cathy Reeser PR MD
11/8/2023 22-ICA-31 Jordan Linzy v. Beckley Galleria, LLC, Paramount Development Corporation, Paramount Development Properties, LLC, Marquee Cinemas, Inc., Marquee Cinemas-WV, Inc., and Marquee Cinemas Holdings, Inc. TCR MD
11/8/2023 22-ICA-81 Amanda Taylor v. Workforce West Virginia and Dismas Charities, Inc., ADM SO
11/1/2023 22-ICA-140 Kevin C. Hawkins v. Randy J. Hawkins TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-189 In re: M.E. CIV-O MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-191 In re: M.M. CIV-O MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-203 Cindy Linger-Long v. Robert M. Milvet and The Board of Trustees of Grant Memorial Hospital Trust Foundation, Inc. (otherwise known as Grant Memorial Hospital) TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-209 Jaymes Faulk v. Mildred Mitchell-Bateman Hospital TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-258 Tammy L. Gilhuys v. Hardy County 911 Center TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-276 Brandon Bickford v. Workforce West Virginia ADM MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-281 Joseph Wells, Individually and as Power of Attorney for Velma Luella Wells v. Antero Resources Corporation, David Bowyer, Ralph D. Harter, and Sylvia M. Harter TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-289 Jay Ferguson v. City of Richwood TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-306 Crystal D. Davis v. Workforce West Virginia ADM MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-314 Daniel Abel v. R. Michael Haywood TCR MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-319 Rebecca C. v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources ADM MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-323 K.C. v. Appalachian Community Health Centers, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-15 Patricia W. v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-16 Bryan W. v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-19 Workforce West Virginia v. Ashley N. Carpenter ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-29 Frank D. Unger and Sherri J. Unger v. Susan Pierce TCR MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-34 Daniel Y. v. Anne Y. FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-51 Otis Martin v. Workforce West Virginia ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-70 Linda M. Jenkins v. West Virginia Board of Social Work ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-71 Linda M. Jenkins v. Deloris Taylor, Brian Taylor, and Marissa Taylor TCR MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-76 Ronald Dale Cork, II v. Dawna Annette Cork FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-81 Wanda Coles, Dependent of Kermit Coles (Deceased) v. Centry Aluminum of West Virginia WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-86 Mountaineer Dough, LLC v. David Milano WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-88 Arthur D. Moore v. Cheri L. Moore FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-93 Marwa A. v. Mohamed A. FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-110 Lewis E. McIntyre v. Judith E. McIntyre FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-117 Matthew K. v. Leigh Ann S. FAM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-134 Logan General Hospital, LLC, d/b/a Logan Regional Medical Center and Rural Health Access Corporation, d/b/a Coalfield Health Center v. Boone Memorial Hospital, Inc. and West Virginia Health Care Authority ADM MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-168 West Virginia Offices of the Clerk Insurance Commissioner, in its capacity as Administrator of the Old Fund v. Eastern Associated Coal, LLC v. Coleen Jarrell, Dependent of Delmer Jarrell (Deceased) WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-187 Kanawha Hospiace Care, Inc. v. Jeannie D. Bostic WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-195 Earl T. Barnett v. Mohigan Mining Co. and West Virginia Offices of the Insurance Commissioner, in its Capacity as Administrator of the Old Fund WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-211 Tractor Supply Company v. Michelle Harper WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-227 Tracy Brownell v. Greenbrier Veterinary Hospital WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-232 Andra L. Gajdos v. Appalachian Electronic Instruments, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-233 Murray American Energy, Inc. v. Connie Titus WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-234 Christopher Ryan v. Metalico, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-244 West Virginia Division of Highways v. Encova Insurance Co. and Victor Shultz, Jr. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-246 Carlos Sanchez v. North Star Painting Company, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-250 Jeffrey Brewer v. ACRN Resources, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-253 Michael Sadaly v. ACNR Resources, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-254 ACNR Resources, Inc. v. Michael Sadaly WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-255 P&G Tabler Station v. David Hiett WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-266 Primecare Medical of West Virginia, Inc. v. Brittany Foster WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-279 Lisa R. Rhodes v. Go-Mart, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-280 Daniel Skipper II v. Mountain State Beverage WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-281 Arcelormittal USA, LLC v. David Saunders WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-300 Deana L. Stone v. CCBCC, Inc. WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-334 Richard Heath v. Alliance Coal, LLC WC MD
11/1/2023 23-ICA-369 ACNR Resources, Inc. v. Robert Murphy WC MD
11/1/2023 22-ICA-83 SWN Production Company, LLC v. City of Weirton and City of Weirton Board of Zoning Appeals CIV-O SO
10/30/2023 23-ICA-22 Kapitus Servicing, Inc. v. Timberline Four Seasons Utilities, Inc. and Canaan Valley Public Service District TCR SO
9/26/2023 23-ICA-312 Mon Valley Technologies, LLC v. Joel Huggins WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-245 Pepsi-Cola Metropolitan Bottling Company, Inc. v. Mohamed A. Gohar WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-228 ICG Tygart Valley, LLC v. Edgar R. Greene WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-216 Kenneth Shrader v. City of Mullens WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-214 Angela Acord v. Family Dollar Stores of WV, LLC WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-205 Murray American Energy, Inc. v. Richard Yost, Jr. WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-202 City of Huntington v. Steven Streets WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-146 Calvin Kirkbride, Jr. v. Ball Metal Food Container Corp., United States Can Co., and Ball Metalpack Aerosol Container and West Virginia Offices of the Insurance Commissioner, in its Capacity as Administrator of the Old Fund WC MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-145 Curtis C. v. Casey V. FAM MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-115 In re: R.T., a minor FAM MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-83 Sharon Tasker v. Agency Insurance Company and Allan L. McVey, Insurance Commissioner of the State of West Virginia ADM MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-67 Justin R. v. Morgan F. FAM MD
9/26/2023 23-ICA-53 Clinton T. Drainer v. Division of Highways ADM MD
9/26/2023 22-ICA-268 Christopher Blake v. West Virginia Department of Education ADM MD
9/26/2023 22-ICA-266 Sara Fields v. Charleston Area Medical Center and Workforce West Virginia ADM MD
9/26/2023 22-ICA-231 Candy Johnson and Princess Johnson v. Brian P. Tanguay CIV-TCR MD
9/11/2023 22-ICA-4
22-ICA-46		 PITA, LLC, and Milan Puskar revocable Trust Restated 9/28/11, v. Scott S. Segal and Scott S. Segal v. PITA, LLC, the Milan Puskar Revocable Trust Restated, 9/28/11 TCR SO
9/5/2023 23-ICA-73 Evan C. v. Ali C. FAM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-62 Heidi Y. v. Jordan C. FAM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-60 Matthew B. v. Kimberly W. FAM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-40 Cheryl Battista v. Andrew Battista FAM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-78 Katherine C. v. A.A. Moore C. FAM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-120 Gordon Martin v. Food Lion, Inc. WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-152 ROC Service Company, LC v. Antonio Smith WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-163 Blackhawk Mining, LLC v. Joseph Browning WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-186 Quinn Transportation, LLC v. Daniel T. Park WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-268 Alcon Laboratories v. Sarah King WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-133 Nicholas Community Action Partnership, Inc. v. Maggie Jarrett WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-188 Emma Harris, Dependent of Carl Harris (Deceased) v. Pine Ridge and The Insurance Commissioner of West Virginia in its capacity as administrator of the Self-Insured Employer Security Risk Pool WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-177 Jeanette Wood, Dependent of John D. Wood (Deceased) v. Pine Ridge Coal Company, LLC and West Virginia Offices of the Insurance Commissioner, in its capacity as administrator of the Guaranty Risk Pool WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-56 Brenda G. Blevins v. Community Hospital Association WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-61 Jennifer Belcher v. West Virginia Parkways Authority WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-14 Caitlin R. Workman v. ACNR Resources, Inc. WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-175 Mark M. Samaan, M.D. v. West Virginia Board of Medicine ADM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-136 Rhino Energy, LLC v. Kenneth Cole WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-195 Clinton T. Drainer v. Division of Highways ADM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-113 Jared Smith v. Arcelormittal WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-197 Gayla Adkins v. Brightspring Healthcare Services WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-331 John J. Delsignore v. Timberline Logging Enterprises, LLC WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-102 Onnie Watson v. Schenker Logistics WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-6 Elmer Hurley v. Chubby's Logging WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-204 Jackie W. Lewis, Sr. v. Columbia West Virginia Corporation WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-161 Stephen Saunders v. ACNR Resources, Inc. WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-156 Virginia Smith, Dependent of Walter F. Smith (Deceased) v. Pine Ridge and The Insurance Commissioner of West Virginia in its capacity as administrator of The Self-insured Employer Security Risk Pool WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-210 Northwest Hardwoods, Inc. v. Mark Ferrell WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-209 Kevin Davis v. Wayne County Board of Education WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-129 Wolf Run Mining, LLC v. Darden Woodford WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-153 Alvin J. Cook, Jr. v. Cecil I. Walker Machinery Co. WC MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-119 Ryan Marstiller v. Masters of Disasters, LLC WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-197 West Virginia Department of Transportation Division of Highways v. Amanda Nicole Justus ADM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-126
23-ICA-139		 Glen Trader v. ACNR Resources, Inc. WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-131 WorkForce West Virginia v. Sara Jonese and Pocahontas County Board of Education ADM MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-110 WorkForce West Virginia v. Christina Gaddy ADM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-2 Abby L. Boyes v. Hospice of Southern West Virginia, Inc. WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-322 Evans Construction Company v. Anthony Schau WC MD
9/5/2023 22-ICA-125 WorkForce West Virginia v. Beverly Kirker ADM MD
9/5/2023 23-ICA-8 West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources Bureau for Child Support Enforcement v. Shawn O. FAM MD