2.  Ulrika Browning, et al. v. Judith Halle, et al, No. 32672. (W.Va. Dec. 1, 2005) (Per Curiam) (Starcher, J. dissents).

Refuse 5- 0

3.   Lillian Gibson v. Northfield Insurance Company, No. 32690. (W.Va. Dec. 2, 2005) (Starcher, J.) (Davis, J. and Benjamin, J. disqualified) (Murensky, Judge and Spaulding, Judge sitting by temporary assignment) (Spaulding, Judge dissents).

Refuse 3-1
[Spaulding, Judge]
[Davis, C.J., Benjamin, J. Disqualified]
[Spaulding, Judge and Murensky, Judge Sitting By Temporary Assignment]

 

Home | Rules | Law Library | Opinions | Site Search | Calendar & Docket